I hate CNN. (Odd Musings)
We here at tilegarden haven't blogged much, if at all, about the war. I cannot speak for my counterpart other than to say that he watches CNN about 16 hours a day.
When I think about war, I think about what I learned in history class, and what I've seen in the movies or on TV. This war has left me with such mixed feelings that I cannot take a side.... other than to say that I wish someone else were Commander in Chief.
This is the first war in which we the public are right there, at the front lines, along with our favorite correspondents from CNN, MSNBC, and whoever else has managed to wiggle their way next to those who are in unbelievable danger right now. Just today, we've had a helicopter accident, an American soldier that mortally wounded at least one of his own, as well as seriously wounding quite a few more, and now CNN is reporting "that it appears" a Patriot missile has likely ENGAGED a Royal Air Force plane!!!!!
I have to admit that I was mildly curious to see what actually happens in a war. That lasted all of about 5 minutes, and then I didn't want to see anymore. One side of me argues that it's the ultimate rubber-necker's dream - you get to possibly see chaos and mayhem, blood and guts, but you don't have to move along! Another part of me thinks that since our troops can't exactly turn off the telly and take a walk, then maybe neither should I. The last part of me thinks that televising and having a running commentary on a WAR is sick, sick, sick.
To me, there is something very sacred about war. Previously, we've only heard about them second-hand, which gives them some kind of reverance. To have it on my television feels like I am cheapening it somehow. As though it has now become entertainment, like a movie or TV show. I am NOT going to get into the rights or wrongs or justifications of this war - however, I do want to get into what is actually happening, right now. There are people my age that are in the middle of the desert, bombing and killing other humans. Maybe having this televised for all to see will show everyone just how awful and horrible war really is. I remember reading in The Century that in WWII, many young men were so gung-ho about going to war, fighting for their country, all very noble - until they actually got over there and started to have to kill fellow human beings, or be killed. Their buddies died before their eyes.
There are Americans in Iraq right now that are having to perform duties and witness things that I so wish did not have to occur. To have them there and me here, all of us watching the same thing, feels so very disrespectful in a way. As though I don't deserve to be sharing this experience with them - after all, they're living it, while I'm merely watching it.
Tonight on CNN, they have been broadcasting actual combat. Am I the only person in America screaming inside my own head, "WHAT IS THIS ON MY TELEVISION FOR?!?!?!?" I feel helpless. It is horrifying that sons, husbands, and fathers (no women have died yet that I know of) cease to be because of an accident!! Who is the enemy here? From what I've read on Yahoo, 22 people have died since this war started, and only 2 of those died in combat! 20 people have died from helicopter accidents, and an American soldier throwing grenades into the tents of his compatriots.
The proverbial straw for me, though, is the press. They say things like, "We are broadcasting this combat live, so anything, anything at all could happen here." Which basically tells me that they're covering their asses for potentially broadcasting flying body parts. Which I get the feeling they'd be all too happy to do, just as long as you keep watching. They are continuously trying to interview The Guy In Charge, who I personally feel needs to be keeping his eye on the situation at hand, NOT chatting with Blitzer about their next objective, keeping in mind of course that he would not divulge any sensitive information. I had to leave the room when they were reporting the possible (probable) RAF aircraft accident. Their voices were so sterile. So devoid of emotion. I do not WANT this to become desensitizing! Our own missile downing an ally's plane is mind-numbingly u n t h i n k a b l e. The very thought makes me cry. To have some idiot drone on and on about the same thing over and over again is a bit insulting ("You know, some might think this march into Baghdad would be a cake walk" - no lie, he said this at least twice. Screw you. Anyone who thought that isn't worth having it explained to them otherwise).
Sorry about the language. I'm feeling extremely frustrated and isolated. I want to support those who are over there, donning gas masks every hour or so, and I do support them. Thinking about you dying over there is so sad. Watching you die over there is unbearable.
Posted by
geena
on Sunday, March 23, 2003 at 01:04 AM
Comments (7)

Comments
Posted by petehed on March 23, 2003 12:58 PM
I must admit that I've been glued to it alot... more like checking my email sort of glued... every hour or two, checking in.
The part that blew me away was the gall of the CNN anchor (dunno his name... pretty boy floyd...) saying that it was reprehensible that the Iraqi TV station was showing pictures of the American troops captured and killed. I laughed at the sheer irony of that comment.
I was also watching that battle last night at about 1:30 am my time... I was fascinated by how absolutely mind numbingly boring it was. I found myself (much to my disgust) going, "hurry up and do something already". I decided then to switch off the TV and go to bed.
The scariest part of this is the desensitization. TV is (and always has been) primarily entertainment, and the 24 hour cable news networks have operated that way since their inception. As soon as something becomes entertainment... it loses a certain amount of reality. That line is so blurred right now... even for me... and I consider myself and pretty non-lamb free-thinking person.
I know I haven't lost my humanity entirely, though... when I saw the tank blow the hell out of the tower of that building, I knew for a fact that I had just watched, live, someone get blown to bits... and it didn't feel very good inside.
Posted by tennille on March 23, 2003 03:45 PM
yup.
Posted by K on March 23, 2003 11:33 PM
Well... I'm not gonna spend enough time to fully weigh in on this right here and now. But overall, my feeling is that news organizations should tell just about anything and everything that they can. Without compromising national security and with the caveat that they should mask soldiers' identities when necessary, to avoid being downright cruel to the families. We the public need to be aware of what's happening, and only we can work to prevent desensitization. I think desensitization can be avoided if we simply take the unheard of step of actually reflecting on what we are seeing.
Posted by p on March 24, 2003 07:13 AM
Kevin, I have to disagree with you there... reflection certainly helps, but desensitization is a natural coping strategy in the face of stress... there is no avoiding it without avoiding the stressor... I bet G can tell you lots about desensitization in her field of work.
Posted by K on March 24, 2003 10:10 AM
If it's so natural and healthy, then why are both of you saying you don't want to be desensitized? I'm confused.
Let's just say there are varying levels of desensitization. Zero being that every report of a casualty you see on the news hits you just as if your own brother had been blown up by a grenade right in front of your eyes. And the maximum being that you were unable to distinguish this report from a killing in a bad TV show. It seems to me that we should all be desensitized enough that we remain capable of thinking with our heads about this, yet not so much that we lose our ability to think with our hearts.
Posted by petehed on March 24, 2003 10:20 AM
I didn't say it was healthy, but it is natural... and necessary.
As always, like you pointed out, it's shades of grey.
Posted by geena on March 24, 2003 12:09 PM
For me, there is a risk of being desensitized. I know that personally, if I keep hearing something, I will eventually become sort of immune to it and it will be more difficult to connect with the situation on a more human level. Hearing about the RAF incident made almost all of my cells curl up, but hearing about it now doesn't elicite quite as visceral of a reaction. Especially after hearing all day yesterday that "these things just happen in war!"
If they were to announce in an hour that another RAF/Patriot incident has just occured, my already desensitized self isn't going to react as strongly.
It is a natural coping mechanism, but another part of me is trying to fight that. I don't want what happens in this war to become "ho hum, another POW, bummer" ... but it will, if I hear about it often enough.
It's hard to strike a balance between really wanting to know what's happening over there and having that curiosity/interest wane over time. I do want to know, btw - I'm more used to seeing it in print instead of live on my TV - That is where my dilemma steps in. I can handle reading about it, I cannot currently handle watching it unfold before me.
My personal thought process is such that if I hear "POW's were made to state their name, blah blah and they were scared/stoic, and there were bodies lying in the background," that's currently enough to make me really sad. Actually seeing it or even hearing the actual soldiers go through this doesn't serve to do much more than twist the knife in an already well-established mental wound. It also has a component of undue humiliation - if I were that POW, I'm not sure I'd want my petrified and vulnerable picture on every TV in the world.
Add a comment